# Dossier 28: Mid-November 2026 Ground-Truth Wave — `qsag` Post-Quantum Custody & WHIR Aggregation, `obend` Wave C3 & `obebuilder` (`obb v6`/`v7`), `compiler-audit` (126 ACL2/SBCL/CCL Bug Classes), `spice-smt-bench` Verified EDA, Active Parallel Fleet & `cv` Errata Ledger

> [!IMPORTANT]
> **Primary-Source Scope & Grounding (`2026-11-14`)**
> This dossier documents the live engineering state across `/Users/ember/dev` through **November 14, 2026**, audited directly against repository working trees, git histories, and `cv` (*clustervision*) session provenance (`10,121` indexed top-level sessions):
> - **Four major post-Nov-11 fronts previously absent or superseded in `whatember`**:
>   1. **[`/Users/ember/dev/qsag`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/README.md)** (`main` @ `629779a`, Nov 13–14): A 14-package zero-`crates.io`-dependency Rust (`>206K` LOC) + 100%-constructive Lean 4.35 (`0 sorry`, `0 Classical.choice`) + Charon/Aeneas MIR + raw Linux Vulkan SPIR-V post-quantum threshold signing, stateful/stateless custody, and $K$-to-1 WHIR/`[CWYZ26]` signature aggregation suite.
>   2. **[`/Users/ember/dev/obend`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/README.md)** (`dev` @ `16fed219` + 4 active Stage-2C worktrees) & **[`/Users/ember/dev/obebuilder`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obebuilder/DESIGN.md)** (`dev` @ `aab42d2`, `obb v7` / `origin/dev` `a672a67`, `obb v6`): Completion of Waves C1–C3, sealing `StageBInstances.lean` (`stageB_cathedral_seven_organ_trace_sealed`) with **zero `*Obligations`** across **597/597 Tier-1 modules**, paired with `obebuilder`'s anti-tautology lints (`lean/judge-fragment-restates-check`) and HMAC-authenticated `JudgeReceipt`s.
>   3. **[`/Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit/README.md)** (`emberian/common-lisp-compiler-audit`, `main` @ `0576b97`) + `common-lisp-compiiler-audit` (`305743a`) + `acl2-fix` (`6c0f3448f6`): Adversarial prover & compiler audit establishing **126 verified distinct root-cause bug classes** (**72 soundness / wrong-code**, **2 security / code-injection**, **52 crash / divergence**) with standalone reproducers across **ACL2 `8.7+`**, **ACL2 Community Books**, **SBCL `2.6.8–2.6.10`/`HEAD`**, and **Clozure CL `1.14`**.
>   4. **[`/Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/README.md)** (`main` @ `eeafe4b`): Zero-dependency Rust (`spice2smt`) + Mathlib-free Lean 4.35 (`0 sorry`, `0 axiom`) verified analog/EDA compiler lowering 6-PDK SPICE netlists (`asap7`, `gt2n`, `ihp_sg13g2`, `gan_sic`, `gf180mcu`, `sky130`), continuous-defect PCB interconnects, and Scharfetter–Gummel TCAD meshes to pure-`exp` SMT-LIB2, native `dReal` ODEs, and 19 Lean 4 `TranscendentalField` targets (`3/19` proved via rational interval paving).
> - **Active parallel fleet reality**: Contrary to the Nov 12 "single-repo consolidation" framing, [`breadstuffs`](file:///Users/ember/dev/breadstuffs) (`18b3abebf`), [`minidregg`](file:///Users/ember/dev/minidregg) (`c60818647` + `append-growth`), [`fn`](file:///Users/ember/dev/fn) (`9849fcebe`), and [`cv`](file:///Users/ember/dev/cv) (`v0.19.3` → `v0.20`) continue vigorous independent development alongside `qsag` and `obend`.

---

## 0. Mid-November 2026 Constellation Snapshot

| Repository | Remote / Branch Tip (`2026-11-14`) | Scale & Substrates | Headline Milestone (Nov 12–14, 2026) | Active Work-in-Progress & Open Gates |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **[`qsag`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/README.md)** | `emberian/qsag` (`main` @ `629779a`, 23 commits) | 14 Rust pkgs (`>206K` LOC, `0` crates.io deps) · 70 Lean 4.35 files (`~243K` LOC, `0 sorry`, **`0 Classical.choice`**) · Charon/Aeneas MIR · 10 Vulkan SPIR-V shaders | FIPS 205 `SLH-DSA` MPC + `Baggy`/`Waistband`/`Jorts`/`QuorumJorts` (`QS-A` ~0.56 ms, `QS-B` Shamir) + `Corduroy`/`Hem` $K$-to-1 WHIR/`[CWYZ26]` aggregator + 6-kernel Lean replay + RX 6750 XT Vulkan ($2^{20}$ Poseidon2 Merkle in `38.77 ms`, `204.6×` CPU) | Persistent VRAM WHIR prover session (`629779a`), `AVX-512`/`GFNI`/`SHA-NI` kernels, `[CWYZ26]` Lemmas 4.5/4.7 (`NonExcludedBound`), ELF `.text` CT fixture refresh, SPDZ/MASCOT soak optimization |
| **[`obend`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/README.md)** | `emberian/obend` (`dev` @ `16fed219`, 898 commits) | 597 Tier-1 Lean 4.35 modules (`664` in `lean/Obend/`, `837` total `.lean`, `0 sorry`) · 6 Rust crates · SV/Verilator/RDNA2 | Wave C2/C3 sealed `StageBInstances.lean` (`stageB_cathedral_seven_organ_trace_sealed`) with **0 `*Obligations`**, 256-bucket `Vault/WorldTree.lean`, 5-stage `SiliconElabFabric`, and P0 soundness/numerics seals (`SymbolicZk`, `CompileToPiop`, `Enclosure`, `SosLyapunov`, `Flowpipe`) | Semiconductor device proofs in `Hardware/Device/{DriftDiffusion,Enclosure,Wafer}.lean` + 4 Stage-2C worktrees (`cubical-core`, `live-cli`, `hw-silicon`, `pde-gpu`) |
| **[`obebuilder`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obebuilder/DESIGN.md)** | `emberian/obebuilder` (`dev` @ `aab42d2` `obb v7` / `origin/dev` `a672a67` `obb v6`) | Rust (`AGPL-3.0-or-later`, 12 CLI subcommands) · `quarry/obend-quarry.toml` | Evolved `obb v2` → `obb v6`/`v7`: `lean/judge-fragment-restates-check`, `lean/pigeonhole-vacuous-premise`, `cross-lang/domain-tag-drift`, 3-way proof/test/`#tooth` split, HMAC-authenticated SHA-bound `JudgeReceipt`s | Updating `quarry/obend-quarry.toml` donor status rows (`5/40` marked `uptaken`) and cone-cached receipt gating |
| **[`compiler-audit`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit/README.md)** | `emberian/common-lisp-compiler-audit` (`main` @ `0576b97`) | 20 audit reports · standalone `repros/` across ACL2 `8.7+`, Books, SBCL `2.6.10`/`HEAD`, CCL `1.14` | **126 verified bug classes** (**72 soundness/wrong-code**): 27 `:ttag nil` ACL2 Core `NIL` bugs (7 pure-kernel zero-book/stobj), 12 Book `NIL` bugs + `SMTLink` Python RCE, 3 SBCL `(safety 3)` bugs proving `NIL` in pure ACL2, 2 CCL `NIL` bugs | Upstream filing & host TCB mitigations for ACL2/SBCL deployments (including `fn`) |
| **[`spice-smt-bench`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/README.md)** | `emberian/spice-smt-bench` (`main` @ `eeafe4b`) | Zero-dep Rust (`spice2smt`) · Mathlib-free Lean 4.35 (`0 sorry`, `0 axiom`) | 6-PDK compact models (`asap7` 7nm FinFET, `gt2n` 2nm GAA, `ihp_sg13g2`, `gan_sic`, `gf180mcu`, `sky130`) + PCB DFM + Scharfetter–Gummel TCAD → `smt2-exp`, `dreal-ode`, & 19 Lean `TranscendentalField` specs (`3/19` proved via `paving_unsat_sound`) | JSON→`PavingNode` bridge, exact rational netlist lexer (bypassing `f64`), proving remaining 16 `Bench_*` targets |
| **[`breadstuffs`](file:///Users/ember/dev/breadstuffs)** | `emberian/breadstuffs` (`origin/main` @ `18b3abebf`, 10,639 commits) | 100+ Rust crates · `Dregg2` Lean 4 (`0 sorry` on updated distributed finality) | Shipped `Turn::is_coordination` → `not_required` proving policy (`18b3abebf`), closed `OPEN-CM-XSORT` blocklace tie-break (`04c093192`), and shipped warm `dregg-client-sign daemon` + ingress macaroons (`025e9057a`) | Landing `DREGG_PROVE_WORKERS=0`, single-vote-per-heartbeat quorum batching, and `DREGG_STORE_CACHE_MB` memory bounds |
| **[`minidregg`](file:///Users/ember/dev/minidregg)** | `emberian/minidregg` (`origin/main` @ `c60818647`, 8,728 commits; 315 lanes) | Lean 4 (`>640K` LOC) · Rust native host & `mini-keys` | Physical `CredentialAuthorityLayout` cell cutover (`lake build Minidregg` green), hashed-bits-first private roots (`ec9749280`), `RelativeFaithful` Simplex induction, log-format-6 erasable commit floor | `append-growth` (`5e05cf4fc`) single-pass private index evaluation & `quiescence preflight` |
| **[`fn`](file:///Users/ember/dev/fn/README.md)** | `emberian/fn` (`main`/`dev` @ `9849fcebe`, 17,551 commits) | 203 ACL2 books (`91.5K` LOC, `3,093` `defthm`s, `95` `:owed` stubs) · 366 Lean 4 files (`431.9K` LOC) | Promoted `fn2` to repo root & purged legacy `fn1` (`49787612f`); landed Nov 13 Assurance Audit (`ASSURANCE-AUDIT-20261113.md`) exposing `durable-turn-inv-p` counterexample & scoping 6 interface pilots (`P0`–`P5`) | Executing pilots `P0` (`defwitness-owed`) through `P5` (closure-wide Lean certificate) + SBCL 2.6.10 host TCB hardening |
| **[`cv`](file:///Users/ember/dev/cv)** | `emberian/cv` (`main` @ `v0.19.3`+ `d95e2143`, 2,830 linear commits) | Rust (`cv-core`, `cv`, `cv-web` WASM, `cv-tauri`) · 22 harnesses | Unified SQLite WAL `~/.clustervision/state.db`, Zstd-Seekable `packs/` + `cv serve --hub`, positional trigram `--exact`, `cv blame`, `cv hook receipt`, `cv lanes --stranded` | Active `v0.20` swarm (`agy_native`, `agy_coverage`, `atomic_index`, `fidelity`) |

---

## 1. `/Users/ember/dev/qsag` — Post-Quantum Threshold Custody, Quorum-Switching Stateful Trees & Constructive WHIR Aggregation

### 1.1 Architectural Thesis & Cryptographic Wardrobe
[`/Users/ember/dev/qsag`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/README.md) (**Quorum-Switching AGgregation / Quantum Succinct AGgregation**, `Apache-2.0 OR MIT`) addresses a concrete post-quantum deployment dilemma across institutional custody and L1 consensus scaling:
- NIST **FIPS 205 `SLH-DSA`** is stateless and rests on minimal hash assumptions, but carries large signatures (7.8–49.8 KiB) and expensive FORS + hypertree hashing inside threshold MPC.
- Stateful hash trees (**XMSS/LMS**) are tiny (~2.5 KiB) and microsecond-fast because they drop horizontal FORS trees, **but** any one-time index reuse across crashes or quorum changes catastrophically breaks security.
- Consensus verifiers (Ethereum Beam Chain, Solana validator sets) need **non-interactive $K$-to-1 post-quantum signature aggregation** with an explicit **128-bit Quantum Random Oracle Model (QROM) Grover floor** and zero classical/non-constructive proof debt.

`qsag` unifies all three regimes inside a **14-package Rust 2024 workspace with zero external `crates.io` dependencies** ([`Cargo.toml`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/Cargo.toml)), backed by **Lean 4.35** (`0 sorry`, **`0 Classical.choice`**), **Charon + Aeneas** Rust MIR extraction, and a zero-dependency **Linux raw Vulkan SPIR-V compute backend**:

```mermaid
flowchart TD
    subgraph Custody["Threshold & Stateful/Stateless Signing (qsag-core, qsag-quorum)"]
        SLH["FIPS 205 SLH-DSA-SHAKE (All 6 Sets)\n2-of-3 RSS & t-of-n SPDZ/MASCOT\n256-lane Bitsliced Keccak + GF(2^128) DZK"]
        BAG["Baggy + Waistband\nStateless Hypertree + Top-L Cache\nWOTS+C (w=4, chains=128, target_sum=192)"]
        JOR["Jorts + BeltLatch (2q > n+f, q <= n-f)\nQS-A CommitteePartitioned (~0.56 ms 2-of-3)\nQS-B BftShamirJorts (Global Tree + MAC-Free Shamir)"]
    end

    subgraph Agg["Algebraic Custody & K-to-1 WHIR Aggregation (qsag-agg, qsag-accel)"]
        CORD["Corduroy\nPoseidon2-12 Goldilocks Hypertree"]
        HEM["Hem Aggregator & Binary-Tree Merger\nGoldilocksExt4 F_p[v]/(v^4 - 7)\nWHIR + [CWYZ26] Affine Monomial v6 + CanopyMultiProof\nHabr24Qrom128 & BciksJohnsonQrom128"]
        VK["qsag-accel Raw Vulkan SPIR-V (10 Shaders)\nRX 6750 XT: 2^20 Poseidon2 Merkle 38.77 ms (204.6x CPU)"]
        CORD --> HEM
        VK --> HEM
    end

    subgraph Ecosystem["Lifecycle, Migration & Credentials"]
        MIG["qsag-migrate\n3-Party Co-ZK Legacy Key Migration\nsecp256k1 / Taproot / Ed25519 (438-rep ZKBoo)"]
        CRED["qsag-cred\nThreshold ML-DSA-44 + 2-of-5 Poseidon2 TOPRF\n6-Limb Quantum128 BlindVC"]
        HD["qsag-hd + qsag-addr + qsag-policy + qsag-fts\nDealerless PQ HD + Bech32m/HybridPinned + BDOZ Velocity Guard"]
    end

    subgraph Proof["Constructive Assurance Stack (0 sorry, 0 Classical.choice)"]
        LEAN["lean/Qsag/* (70 .lean files, ~243K LOC)\naxioms ⊆ {propext, Quot.sound}\n6-Kernel Replay: lean, leanchecker, lean4lean, nanoda, con-leche, con-ron"]
        AEN["aeneas/lean (44 mods) + aeneas/lean-whir (7 mods)\nCharon + Aeneas Rust MIR Equivalence (0 FunsExternal)"]
        CT["ConstantTimeIsa.lean + dudect + AVX2/AVX-512/NEON"]
    end

    Custody --> Proof
    Agg --> Proof
    Ecosystem --> Proof
```

1. **`Baggy` + `Waistband` ([`crates/qsag-core`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/crates/qsag-core))**: Implements all 6 NIST FIPS 205 `SLH-DSA-SHAKE` parameter sets (`128s/f`, `192s/f`, `256s/f`) in both honest-majority 2-of-3 Replicated Secret Sharing (RSS) and dishonest-majority $t$-of-$n$ SPDZ/MASCOT MPC, alongside `BaggySha3` and `BaggyPoseidon2`. Combines `Waistband` (a static Top-$L$ internal child-root & WOTS public-key cache), 256-lane bitsliced MPC Keccak-$f[1600]$, hardware carry-less $GF(2^{128})$ BGIN19 distributed zero-knowledge checks (`PCLMULQDQ` / `VPCLMULQDQ` / `PMULL`), and zero-checksum **`WOTS+C`** (`w = 4`, `chains = 128`, `target_sum = 192`).
2. **`Jorts`, `BeltLatch`, & Quorum-Switching (`QS-A` / `QS-B` in [`crates/qsag-quorum`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/crates/qsag-quorum))**:
   - **`Jorts`** eliminates horizontal FORS trees (`t = 2, n = 3`), yielding ~2.5 KiB post-quantum signatures guarded by a crash-safe POSIX write-ahead log (`PosixCrashWal.lean`) and certified **`BeltLatch`** quorum intersection ($2q > n + f$ and $q \le n - f$ for $n \ge 3f + 1$).
   - **Mode `QS-A` (`CommitteePartitionedJorts`)**: Allocates $\binom{n}{t}$ disjoint subtrees per signer subset, achieving **~0.56 ms** 2-of-3 loopback TCP threshold signing with zero cross-committee state coordination.
   - **Mode `QS-B` (`BftShamirJorts`)**: Shares a single global public key across changing quorums by combining a BFT `BeltLatch` monotonic lease with MAC-free, self-verifying pre-stepped Shamir `WOTS+C` shares.
3. **`Corduroy` & `Hem` $K$-to-1 Aggregation ([`crates/qsag-agg`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/crates/qsag-agg))**:
   - Pair algebraic `Poseidon2-12` hypertrees (`Corduroy`) with **`Hem`**, a non-interactive $K$-to-1 signature aggregator and recursive binary-tree proof merger (`Hem::merge`) over the degree-4 extension **`GoldilocksExt4`** ($\mathbb{F}_p[v]/(v^4 - 7)$, $p = 2^{64} - 2^{32} + 1$).
   - Uses rate-escalating EUROCRYPT 2025 **WHIR** + the **`[CWYZ26]` (`ePrint 2026/2863`) v6 affine monomial protocol** (`crates/qsag-agg/AFFINE_PROTOCOL.md`) + Steiner-deduplicated **`CanopyMultiProof`**, shipping two explicit 128-bit QROM profiles: conditional proximity-gap **`Habr24Qrom128`** ($q = (128, 64, 43, 32)$) and **unconditional Johnson-bound `BciksJohnsonQrom128`** ($q = (258, 130, 88, 66)$) with an enforced 128-bit Grover query floor.
4. **Lifecycle, Migration, Credentials & GPU Acceleration**:
   - **[`crates/qsag-migrate`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/crates/qsag-migrate)**: Active 3-party co-ZK ownership migration proving knowledge of legacy `secp256k1` / Bitcoin Taproot / `Ed25519` secret keys inside MPC (438-repetition ZKBoo) to authorize PQ rotation **without ever reconstructing the legacy scalar on any single machine**.
   - **[`crates/qsag-cred`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/crates/qsag-cred)**: Threshold FIPS 204 `ML-DSA-44` ($2t - 1$ corruption bound), 2-of-5 Poseidon2 TOPRF, and 6-limb `Quantum128` BlindVC credentials; plus `qsag-fts`, `qsag-hd`, `qsag-addr` (`Bech32m` + `HybridPinnedEnvelope`), `qsag-policy` (rolling-window BDOZ guard), `qsag-asm` (`AVX2`, `AVX-512`, `GFNI`, `PCLMULQDQ`, `SHA-NI`, `NEON`/`EOR3`), and `qsag-cli`.
   - **[`crates/qsag-accel`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/crates/qsag-accel)**: Dynamic `dlopen("libvulkan.so.1")` raw Linux Vulkan compute engine embedding **10 SPIR-V shaders** (`shaders/*.comp`). On an AMD Radeon RX 6750 XT (`RADV` Wave32), builds a $2^{20}$-leaf Poseidon2 Merkle tree in **38.77 ms** (**204.6×** faster than CPU), computes 262,144 Poseidon2-12 hashes in **27.38 ms** (**78.1×** CPU), and runs a $2^{20}$ Goldilocks NTT in **21.40 ms**.

### 1.2 100%-Constructive Lean 4.35 Formalization, 6-Kernel Replay & Honest Open Gates
- **Zero `Classical.choice` (`d415130`, `2026-11-14`)**: Every theorem across [`lean/`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/lean) (**70 `.lean` files**, ~243K LOC; pre-coding-theory census: **59,257 declarations / 28,744 theorems**) and [`aeneas/`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/aeneas) checks with **`0 sorryAx`, `0` custom axioms, and `0 Classical.choice`** (`axioms ⊆ {propext, Quot.sound}`).
- **6-Kernel Independent Replay & Charon/Aeneas MIR**: Exported proof artifacts replay across **`lean`**, **`leanchecker --fresh`** (paranoid), **`lean4lean`**, **`nanoda_bin`**, **`con-leche`**, and **`con-ron`**, while `aeneas/lean` (**5,318 decls / 2,093 theorems / 44 modules**, `0 FunsExternal`) and `aeneas/lean-whir` (**1,558 decls / 718 theorems / 7 modules**) verify safe-Rust MIR equivalence for `Goldilocks`, `Poseidon2-12`, `Merkle`, `BeltLatch`, `RssShare`, `ShamirWots`, `Canopy`, and the WHIR verifier.
- **Mechanized `[CWYZ26]` Algebraic Coding Theory (`lean/Qsag/CodingTheory/*`)**: Across 9 new modules (`PolyMv3`, `SylvesterResultant`, `DynamicGcdSplit`, `HenselNumerators`, `UniversalHenselLift`, `SimpleRootStratification`, `TrivariateGsExplainer`, `AffineIncidenceBound`, `Cwyz26AffineGap`), `qsag` constructively proves `[CWYZ26]` Lemma 3.11, Claim 4.9, Hasse-derivative simple-root stratification (avoiding a $D^2$ Yun–Gauss blowup), Lemma 4.2 trivariate Guruswami–Sudan explainer vanishing, and `cwyz26_affineMcaBound_of_nonExcluded` (`|E| ≤ D_y`), while refuting an earlier false `L ≤ D^2 + 2dD` claim (`affineMcaBound_ge_card`).
- **Active Work & Honest Open Boundaries (`629779a`, [`ASSURANCE.md`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag/ASSURANCE.md))**:
  1. **Solana / Ethereum Scaling VRAM WHIR Session (`629779a`)**: Actively wiring persistent GPU VRAM `Hem` WHIR prover sessions (`vkCmdFillBuffer` zeroization + 4 new WHIR fold/LDE shaders) and Zen 5 `AVX-512`/`GFNI`/`SHA-NI` kernels (`avx512.rs`).
  2. **ELF `.text` Constant-Time Fixture Freshness**: After recent Rust/ASM edits, `0/16` x86-64 and `6/7` AArch64 ELF `.text` hashes match historical pinned fixtures (`scripts/audit_elf_ct.py`) pending fresh certificate regeneration.
  3. **SPDZ/MASCOT Soak Timeouts & Beam Mock Latency**: Malicious-majority SPDZ/MASCOT bit-triple preprocessing still times out on multi-minute soak tests (honest-majority RSS runs in milliseconds), `Hem` Beam-chain mock verify latency is currently **75.4 ms** vs. the **<8 ms** target, `[CWYZ26]` Lemmas 4.5/4.7 (`NonExcludedBound` over $\mathbb{F}[Z]$-irreducible factors) remain open, and `aeneas/lean/PILLAR_STATUS.md` notes a sibling-snapshot identifier drift on `RssSlhFullSecurity` when rebuilding custody welds against root.

---

## 2. `/Users/ember/dev/obend` Waves C1–C3 (`16fed219`) & `/Users/ember/dev/obebuilder` (`obb v6`/`v7`)

Between November 12 (`216ef6d` in `whatember`) and November 14, 2026, both [`/Users/ember/dev/obend`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/README.md) (`898` commits on `dev`) and [`/Users/ember/dev/obebuilder`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obebuilder/DESIGN.md) (`AGPL-3.0-or-later`) crossed major structural milestones that supersede the Nov 12 Stage-A charter:

1. **Stage-B Cathedral Apex Sealed (`4d2cc0e0`, Wave C2)**:
   - Consolidated `72 → 9` GPU/Lower/Analysis modules (`39dba74f`), purged 41 barrel/deadweight fossils (`4246ad20`), deleted legacy `crates/obend-node` and `sandstorm/` (`3df8eb96`), and wired all **597 Tier-1 library modules** into [`lean/Obend.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/lean/Obend.lean) (`664` `.lean` files in `lean/Obend/` including `55` mutation modules in `Obend/Teeth/` and `7` in `Obend/Apps/`; **837 `.lean` files total** across `lean/`).
   - In [`lean/Obend/Trailblaze/StageBInstances.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/lean/Obend/Trailblaze/StageBInstances.lean) (`4,985` lines) + [`CathedralApex.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/lean/Obend/Trailblaze/CathedralApex.lean) (`3,173` lines), proved **`stageB_cathedral_seven_organ_trace_sealed`** and all four subsystem seals (`stageB_polis_deos_trace_sealed`, `stageB_lean_fpga_rung2_to_rung5_sealed`, `stageB_zkstripe_calltree_sealed`, `stageB_clustergov_ozaki_step_sealed`) with **zero `[...Obligations]` typeclass parameters**, mechanically enforced by `MetaM` `forallTelescope` inspection + `#print axioms` + 6 `#tooth` mutation kills in [`lean/tests/metasystem/TrailblazeStageBSealTest.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/lean/tests/metasystem/TrailblazeStageBSealTest.lean).
   - Upgraded Organ `O1` to a **256-bucket** COW Verkle world tree + torn-write WAL ([`lean/Obend/Vault/WorldTree.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/lean/Obend/Vault/WorldTree.lean)), validated **5-stage `SiliconElabFabric`** + **AMD RDNA2** RX 6750 XT binaries + schedule-invariant `Ozaki` integer-sliced collectives, replaced broken `CofibLUT16` with `FaceIdeal3` (`BitVec 27`), and verified all 13 root docs against `Lean.Environment` via `#check_docs_census`.
2. **Wave C3 P0 Soundness & Numerics Seals (`7b91227f`..`16fed219`, Nov 13)**:
   - Closed P0 soundness and interval/enclosure bugs across `SymbolicZk`, `CompileToPiop` sumcheck binding, `Transcript` squeeze phase, `WorkbookEngine` redaction, `AutoCert` receiver qualification, `Enclosure`, `SosLyapunov`, `Flowpipe`, `Hybrid`, `Epistemic`, and `QuantumWalk`.
   - **Active in-flight work (`2026-11-14`)**: Semiconductor device verification in `lean/Obend/Hardware/Device/{DriftDiffusion,Enclosure,Wafer}.lean` plus 4 active Stage-2C worktrees (`swarm-s2-cubical-core-43d56b4d` @ `ee922ed0`, `swarm-s2-live-cli-ac3ec0c7` @ `65256788`, `swarm-s2-hw-silicon-995b736d`, `swarm-s2-pde-gpu-48ecb9a6`).
3. **`obebuilder` Evolution (`obb v2` → `obb v6` `0.6.0` on `origin/dev` `a672a67` / `obb v7` `0.7.0` locally `aab42d2`)**:
   - Added `obb harness` (`obb v4`), **three high-leverage anti-vacuity lints (`obb v5`, `d7dcd26`)** — `lean/judge-fragment-restates-check` (blocking `Judge.Fragment` definitions that tautologically restate the operational checker), `lean/pigeonhole-vacuous-premise` (catching unsatisfiable Minkowski/Pigeonhole norm bounds), and `cross-lang/domain-tag-drift` (scanning Rust ↔ Lean domain-separation tags) — **3-way proof / test / `#tooth` separation (`obb v6`, `a672a67`)**, and **HMAC-authenticated SHA-bound `JudgeReceipt`s + cone receipt caching + `obb state` (`obb v7`, `aab42d2`, 12 CLI subcommands)**. Note also that `quarry/obend-quarry.toml` lives in [`/Users/ember/dev/obebuilder/quarry/obend-quarry.toml`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obebuilder/quarry/obend-quarry.toml), whereas `obend` itself carries [`quarry/obend-apex.toml`](file:///Users/ember/dev/obend/quarry/obend-apex.toml) (238 `[[apex]]` entries).

---

## 3. `/Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit` — 126 Verified Bug Classes Across ACL2 `8.7+`, Community Books, SBCL & Clozure CL

Initiated via the consistency ledger & differential route-matrix harness in `/Users/ember/dev/common-lisp-compiiler-audit` (`305743a`, which tested 360,000 Dietz-style typed integer forms and diagnosed in `RESEARCH.md` why random arithmetic misses prover `ttree`, `:df`, and rollback soundness bugs) and an earlier upstream ACL2 `#2055` kernel fix in `/Users/ember/dev/acl2-fix` (`6c0f3448f6`), **[`/Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit/README.md)** (`emberian/common-lisp-compiler-audit`, `main` @ `0576b97`, `2026-11-13`) executed a 4-wave adversarial audit + Z3 SMT IR equivalence + XDsmith fuzzing campaign across `darwin-arm64` and `x86-64-linux`.

Every one of the **126 distinct root-cause bug classes** ships with a standalone reproducer in [`repros/`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit/repros) and root-cause analysis in [`reports/`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit/reports/README.md):

| Target System | Soundness / Wrong-Code | Security / Sandbox / RCE | Crash / Divergence | Total Distinct Bug Classes | Headline `(defthm ... nil)` / Wrong-Code Findings |
| :--- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | :--- |
| **ACL2 `8.7+` (`1d2b39a424`) Core** | **27** (`29` root causes) | **1** (`PSC-S2` sandbox write) | **27** | **55** | **7 pure-kernel `:ttag nil` zero-book/zero-stobj proofs of `NIL`** (`PK-S1..S6`, `PK-E1`: `type-set` & `bind-free` `ttree` `'assumption` drops, `meta-extract-contextual-fact` forced assumptions, proof-builder `:apply-linear` sibling governor leak, `encapsulate` local `defun$` warrant drop, `badge-table :clear`, `bad-ancestor1` diagonal loop) + **8 translator/`:df`/`loop$` `NIL` proofs** (`XDS-S1..S5`, `S4/S5/S7`) + **6 `:ttags nil` cache/stobj/rollback `NIL` proofs** (`SCR-S1..S3`, `WRB-S1/S2/S4`) + **4 `.sao`/`#Y`/book-boundary `NIL` proofs** |
| **ACL2 Community Books** | **12** | **1** (`FV-5` `SMTLink` Python RCE) | **11** | **24** | `(defthm ... nil)` `Q.E.D.` in `centaur/misc/fast-alist-pop-raw.lsp` (`rplacd` missing `invariant-risk`), `SULFA`, `centaur/aig/aig-vars-fast.lisp` (2 bugs), `centaur/gl/bfr-fraig-satlink.lisp` (non-local `(remove-untouchable create-state t)`), `SMTLink` verified `uninterpreted-fn-cp.lisp` Z3 variable shadowing, `SATlink`, and `ACL2s` (`defdata-attach`, `definec-core`, `match.lisp`) |
| **SBCL `2.6.8–2.6.10` & `HEAD`** | **15** (`14` at `(safety 3)`) | 0 | **8** (`4` `HEAD` 0-day ICEs) | **23** | **3 pure `:logic`-mode `:ttag nil` zero-book proofs of `NIL` in unmodified ACL2 8.7+** caused solely by SBCL `2.6.10` `(safety 3)` miscompilations: `srctran.lisp:4084` `ash-inverted`, `constraint-back.lisp:505` `char-code` interval negation, and `equality-constraints.lisp:153` `inherit-equality-p` folding `(eql #\a #\A)` to `T` |
| **Clozure CL `1.14`** | **18** (`14` at `(safety 3)`) | 0 | **4** | **22** | **2 `:ttag nil` proofs of `NIL` in ACL2 8.7+**: a **1-event, 13-step `NIL` proof** via `to-dfp-of-rize` + CCL `%double-float` violating CLHS `(= (float (rationalize f) f) f)` on subnormals (`W4-KC-1`), and `arm642-vref1` omitting `* 4` byte scaling on bit-vectors `> 131040` (`W4-KC-2`); plus `(space 0)` silently overriding `(safety 3)` to `(safety 0)` across inline calls (`CCL-CG-2`) |
| **Cross-System / Harness** | 0 | 0 | **2** | **2** | Differential harness & certification-boundary divergences |
| **Total** | **72** | **2** | **52** | **126** | Full index in [`compiler-audit/reports/README.md`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit/reports/README.md) |

---

## 4. `/Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench` — Multi-PDK SPICE, PCB EM & TCAD Verification in SMT-LIB2, `dReal` & Lean 4.35

[`/Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/README.md) (`main` @ `eeafe4b`, `2026-11-13`) builds a zero-external-crate Rust compiler (`spice2smt`) paired with a Mathlib-free Lean 4.35 library ([`lean/SpiceSmtBench/`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/lean/SpiceSmtBench), `0 sorry`, `0 axiom`) for **physically grounded analog, power, interconnect, and TCAD formal verification**:
- **Physics & Multi-PDK Coverage (19 Graded Benchmarks)**: Compiles SPICE + `.verify` decks covering linear/transient elements (`R`, `G`, `C`, `L`, `V`, `I`), Shockley diodes with series `RS`, **6 multi-PDK `.pdk` compact models** (`asap7` 7nm FinFET, `gt2n` 2nm GAA nanosheet, `ihp_sg13g2` 130nm SiGe HBT, `gan_sic` 48V GaN HEMT, `gf180mcu` 180nm dual-well SCR/ESD, `sky130`), `.interconnect` Hammerstad–Jensen / Kirschning–Jansen microstrip & coupled differential pairs under continuous manufacturing-defect fields, and `.tcad` 1D/2D/electro-thermal Scharfetter–Gummel Bernoulli drift-diffusion meshes.
- **Three Target Backends**:
  1. `--dialect smt2-exp`: Pure-`exp` SMT-LIB2 (`(set-logic ALL)` or `--logic QF_NRAT`), encoding `ln(1+z)` and smooth `sqrt` via `exp` witnesses (`ln1p_exp`, `smooth_sqrt`) and Backward-Euler / Trapezoidal discrete transient collocation.
  2. `--dialect dreal-ode`: Native continuous-time ODE verification (`QF_NRA_ODE`, `define-ode` + `forall_t`) over explicit state equations $\dot{x} = C(x)^{-1}(Bu(t) - Gx - i_{\text{nl}}(x))$.
  3. `--dialect lean4`: Shortest-roundtrip exact decimal rational target propositions ([`TargetsGenerated.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/lean/SpiceSmtBench/TargetsGenerated.lean), 19 `Bench_*` propositions parameterized over explicit `(TF : TranscendentalField R)`).
- **Kernel-Checked Rational Interval Paving (`IntervalCheck.lean`, `Targets.lean`) & Honest Scope**:
  - [`IntervalCheck.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/lean/SpiceSmtBench/IntervalCheck.lean) proves `evalExpr_sound`, monotone rational scaling-and-squaring (`exp_ge_qrat_iterSq`: $(1 + q/2^m)^{2^m} \le \exp(x)$), `checkConcreteLeaf_sound`, and `paving_unsat_sound` over `AlgebraicOrderedField.qrat`.
  - **3 of the 19 generated `Bench_*` targets are currently proved end-to-end in [`Targets.lean`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/lean/SpiceSmtBench/Targets.lean)**: `Bench_01_diode_clipper_pvt` (both directly and via 2-leaf paving), `Bench_06_rc_diode_glitch_filter_ode` (6-step Backward-Euler barrier), and `Bench_09a_pcb_microstrip_dfm_unsat` (23-box 5-parameter PCB DFM paving certificate in `PcbCertificate.lean`), alongside standalone bandgap Trojan/startup lemmas. The remaining 16 `Bench_*` specs, JSON→`PavingNode` parsing, and `f64`-free netlist lexing are explicitly documented as open in [`README.md:145-171`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench/README.md#L145-L171).

---

## 5. Active Parallel Fleet Progress (Nov 12–14, 2026)

1. **`breadstuffs` (`origin/main` @ `18b3abebf`, `10,639` commits)**:
   - **Turn-Level Proving Modality Policy (`18b3abebf`, `breadstuffs-dep-policy-2`)**: Directly closes Directive 23 ("modalities that don't produce a full STARK all the time") across 49 files: pure coordination turns (`Turn::is_coordination`, zero balance delta, self-emitted events only) receive an explicit `not_required` proving disposition (signature + committee attestation, failing closed on federation/light-client paths unless `--force-prove-all`).
   - **Unified Blocklace Tie-Break (`04c093192`, `breadstuffs-dep-tiebreak`)**: Closes `OPEN-CM-XSORT` across Rust (`blocklace/src/ordering.rs`, `node/src/finality_gate.rs`) and Lean 4 (`Dregg2/Distributed/BlocklaceFinality.lean`, `TauPrefixMonotone.lean`, `0 sorry` across all 18 importers) using shared deterministic priority `(round, seq, creator, source_id)`.
   - **Warm Client Signer Daemon & Attenuated Ingress Macaroons (`025e9057a`, `breadstuffs-dep-signer`)**: Ships `dregg-client-sign daemon` behind a `0600` Unix socket batching `(id, topic, digest)` anchors with crash-safe `undecided` nonce blocking, plus `POST /api/auth/mint-ingress`.
2. **`minidregg` (`origin/main` @ `c60818647`, `8,728` commits; `315` `minidregg-lanes/*` entries)**:
   - **Physical Authority Cell Cutover (`f4651f6a1..c60818647`, `ea25a8d9c`)**: Completed Lean + native host cutover of `.authority` to `Compiler.CredentialAuthorityLayout` (`BirthAuthorityWritesBounded`, whole `lake build Minidregg` green), hashed-bits-first private root indexing (`ec9749280`), `RelativeFaithful` Simplex induction (`538456cbf`), log-format-6 erasable commit floor (`aac9eba60`), and active `append-growth` (`5e05cf4fc`) single-pass private index evaluation + `quiescence preflight`.
3. **`fn` (`main`/`dev` @ `9849fcebe`, `17,551` commits)**:
   - On Nov 1 (`49787612f`), `fn2` was promoted to `/Users/ember/dev/fn` root and the legacy `fn1` tree (`1,440` books / `652K` LOC) was retired. Live `fn` comprises **203 ACL2 books (`91,457` LOC, `3,093` `defthm`s, `95` unproved `defthm-owed` stubs)**, a ~1.9 KLOC SBCL + C FFI host (including qualified native C BLAKE3 in `host/b3-native.lisp`), and **366 Lean 4 files (`431,948` LOC)** in `meta/` (`0 sorryAx`).
   - On Nov 13 (`c8bbf9bbc`, `9849fcebe`), [`docs/design/ASSURANCE-AUDIT-20261113.md`](file:///Users/ember/dev/fn/docs/design/ASSURANCE-AUDIT-20261113.md) and [`ASSURANCE-PLAN-20261113.md`](file:///Users/ember/dev/fn/docs/design/ASSURANCE-PLAN-20261113.md) documented that top-level durability (`commit-durable-all.lisp`), turn budgets (`reference.lisp`), and native host refinement (`owed-native.lisp`) remain `:owed`, recorded an **executed counterexample** (`319620bed`, `tests/dur-turn-counterexample.lisp`) refuting the arbitrary-state invariant `durable-turn-inv-p` in favor of reachable-state `reachable-durable-state-p`, and launched 6 falsifiable interface pilots (`P0`–`P5`).
4. **`zkml-research` (`b950c991`), `degg-research` (`8af679e`), `lean-transport` (`44fae29`), & `cv` (`v0.19.3` → `v0.20`)**:
   - `zkml-research` imported the full **162-file `Selvage` tower** with git history (`579a425e`, `b950c991`, including `AuthMapCommitment.lean` `7b3468acf` repairing injective commitment modeling).
   - `degg-research` (`113` commits) added Lean 4 Ariadne chokepoint state-continuity (`8af679e`) and `mma-accumulator-probe` CUDA rotation/FP16/Tower256 experiments.
   - `lean-transport` (`44fae29`) built an `.olean` link-farm + transitive-blocking proof-repair driver for representation changes.
   - `cv` (`v0.19.3` + `d95e2143` + active `v0.20` swarm `codex:01a1dc1f-d`) shipped unified SQLite WAL `~/.clustervision/state.db`, Zstd-Seekable `packs/` + `cv serve --hub` replication, positional trigram `--exact` search, `cv blame`, `cv hook receipt`, structural `cv lanes --stranded`, and 22 real harnesses (including `antigravity`).

---

## 6. `cv` Provenance Archaeology & Ground-Truth Misconception Errata Ledger

Using `cv ls --cwd /Users/ember/dev/whatember`, `cv touched`, `cv blame`, and `cv search "whatember"` across all 10,121 indexed sessions, we traced every wave that previously wrote `whatember` and audited their claims against live source code:
- **Wave 1 (`2026-11-02`, `0017e0a`..`7cbd65f`)**: Seven Claude Opus dossier subagents (`claude:b5ef1c0a-3`, `4a757072-4`, `2f2dc38c-b`, `11fccaae-e`, `c48ceb7d-a`, `24141aa1-2`, `3ba52533-4`) + direct re-scout subagents (`Dossiers 16..27`).
- **Wave 2 (`2026-11-05..07`, `0b31466`..`2acc58b`)**: `claude:78fef112` (`LUCID-INTERVIEW-BRIEF`, `INITIATIVES.md` rows 1–19, `DIRECTIVES-DIG-2026-11-07.md`), `codex:01a1b278` (`SWARM-2026-11-05-SYNTHESIS.md`), and `codex:01a1b758-d` (`gpt-6-astra`, `ASTRA-DIRECTION-REVIEW-2026-11-07.md`).
- **Wave 3 (`2026-11-12`, `3426a76`..`216ef6d`)**: `antigravity:b2b581fc` / subagent `antigravity:54406378` (`W-Whatember`, `PROGRAM-2026-11-12-obend-cathedral-and-trimodel-roadmap.md`).

### Key Misconceptions & Hallucinations Corrected Across `whatember` on `2026-11-14`
1. **Fabricated Repos & False Vertical Summaries in `README.md`**: Removed 5 non-existent repository names (`teach`, `sensei`, `notecard`, `pbot1`, `polymarket-arb`) and corrected `abcdeez` (Graph-Coded Mental Models via Bayesian EIG + IRT, explicitly *not* spaced repetition), `dclutch` (complete-set integer collateral + KKT LP duality + Base-2 Q62 LMSR, *0* uses of "Bregman projection"), `joshi` (read-only observatory with *"No signer, by design"*, not an autonomous market-maker), `audec` (unverified "reverse DAW" prototype with zero neural runs, marked *Compost/ditch* Oct 10 — not "verified neural audio codecs"), and `allgame` (`52` tools / `18` grouped ops and `4` cache tiers `T1`–`T4`, `MotherMythos` resident; `konishi` is a lore protocol, not an agent).
2. **Five Fabricated Code Blocks & `stella` `cheat` Overclaim in Dossier 25**: Replaced all 5 invented code snippets (`Fn2/Square.lean`, `Arbitration.thy`, `stellaMLLScript.sml`, `svenvs/apex/apexScript.sml`, `verekos/world/World/CarryForward.lean`) with verbatim source lines, and corrected `stella/hol/` from *"301 kernel-checked theorems"* to `155` theorem declarations across 9 files with **`83` active HOL4 `cheat` tactics across 7/9 files** (only `stellaTermScript` and `stellaPolarisedScript` are `cheat`-free).
3. **`o7vn` (`veri7vn`), `leanuweave`, `clairnets`, `svenvs`, & Plonky3 `52e1fab` Misdescriptions**: Corrected `o7vn` (Oracle7 STEM & SQLite relation-reader specialists, frozen after `9396b68c`, *zero* connection to regulatory compliance), `leanuweave` (`Ancestral.clash_dichotomy` over Bailis `IConfluent` resurrection vs. accumulation — *not* a "DAG-CRDT dichotomy theorem"), `clairnets` (only 3 small bases Pythia-160M/OLMo-2-1B/SmolLM3-3B were Stage-2 woven; the 4 large 8B–32B bases ran init-only `graft_organ` smoke checks, and `bank_woven.py` headline numbers use provided ground-truth CSP graphs), `svenvs` (sidesteps Löb's obstruction via a frozen root checker + reduces kernel self-strengthening to `lcaTheory`, rather than "discharging Löb's obstruction"), and Plonky3 `52e1fab` (verifier read `num_queries` from the untrusted proof, accepting 1-query FRI proofs — *not* "query-index deduplication").
4. **Dossier 07 & 22 Pre-Consolidation `obend` Paths & `atlas.html` Stale Rows**: Flagged the non-existent pre-Wave-C1 `obend` paths/SHAs (`Obend/Core/Term.lean` 25–26 constructors vs. never-existing `Core/AST.lean`), replaced `atlas.html`'s 16 stale early-scout rows (`108+`/`62`/`49`/`5` commits, `nanodregg` misattributed consensus, `automatafl` misattributed automata learning) with a comprehensive ground-truth inventory, corrected `cv`'s 22 real harnesses and linear commit count in Dossier 27, and corrected seven false *"exists nowhere"* dismissals in `DIRECTIVES-DIG-2026-11-07.md` (`DatalogCert`, `dclutch` Solana Lean, `WpGenerator`, `lean-transport`, `DagPcd`, `AuthMapCommitment`, `OpenHypergraph`).
