# Initiatives register

The one place every initiative is listed, so none is forgotten and none quietly shrinks below the sophistication
it was opened for. Rungs: **L0** idea with stated falsifier, **L1** audited Lean statement (`0 sorry`, anti-vacuity clean),
**L2** construction whose accept decision routes through the Lean statement, **L3** end-to-end (**Silver**) on a real
artifact and re-runnable by a stranger, **L4** (**Golden**) composed with external/hardware oracles, `0` open
`[Obligations]` in `CathedralApex.lean`, and `#tooth`-bitten in public.

---

## I. Active Constellation & Cathedral Register (`2026-11-14` Ground-Truth Update)

**Constellation Reality (`2026-11-14`, see [`Dossier 28`](sources/strands/28-november-2026-midmonth-wave-qsag-obend-c3-compiler-audit-spice.md)):**
Rather than freezing all work into a single repository, mid-November 2026 engineering runs across **two complementary tracks**:
1. **The `obend` + `obebuilder` (`obb v6`/`v7`) Cathedral (`~/dev/obend` @ `16fed219`, `~/dev/obebuilder` @ `aab42d2`):**
   Waves C1–C3 consolidated `72 → 9` GPU/Lower/Analysis modules, purged legacy facades (`obend-node`, `sandstorm/`), wired all **597/597 Tier-1 library modules** (`664` `.lean` files in `lean/Obend/`, `837` total `.lean` files; `238` entries in `obend/quarry/obend-apex.toml`), and **sealed Stage-B (`StageBInstances.lean` + `CathedralApex.lean`, `stageB_cathedral_seven_organ_trace_sealed`) with zero `[...Obligations]` parameters** (`4d2cc0e0`), followed by Wave C3 P0 soundness & numerics seals (`16fed219`). `obebuilder` advanced from `obb v2` to **`obb v6` (`0.6.0` on `origin/dev` `a672a67`) / `obb v7` (`0.7.0` locally `aab42d2`)** (`AGPL-3.0-or-later`, 12 CLI subcommands, anti-tautology `lean/judge-fragment-restates-check`, `lean/pigeonhole-vacuous-premise`, `cross-lang/domain-tag-drift`, 3-way proof/test/`#tooth` separation, HMAC-authenticated SHA-bound `JudgeReceipt`s, and `/Users/ember/dev/obebuilder/quarry/obend-quarry.toml`). Legacy `Oracle7` remains severed (`9396b68`), and standalone `o7vn` (`veri7vn`) remains archived.
2. **Vigorous Independent Research & Production Campaigns:**
   Greenfield **`qsag`** (`629779a`, PQ threshold signing & WHIR/`[CWYZ26]` aggregation), **`compiler-audit`** (`0576b97`, 126 verified ACL2/Books/SBCL/CCL bug classes), **`spice-smt-bench`** (`eeafe4b`, 6-PDK SPICE/PCB/TCAD → SMT2/`dReal`/Lean 4), plus active feature & formal-proof lanes in **`breadstuffs`** (`18b3abebf`), **`minidregg`** (`c60818647` + `append-growth`), **`fn`** (`9849fcebe`), and **`cv`** (`v0.19.3` → `v0.20`).

### I-A. Independent Flagship Campaigns (`2026-11-14`)

| ID | Initiative & Repository | Stack & Scale | Landed Ground Truth (`2026-11-14`) | Rung Now | Active Next Gate | Last Report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **QS1** | **Post-Quantum Threshold Custody & Constructive WHIR Aggregation** ([`~/dev/qsag`](file:///Users/ember/dev/qsag)) | 14 Rust pkgs (`0` crates.io deps, `>206K` LOC) · 70 Lean 4.35 files (`0 sorry`, **`0 Classical.choice`**) · Charon/Aeneas MIR · 10 Vulkan SPIR-V shaders | FIPS 205 `SLH-DSA` RSS/SPDZ + `Baggy`/`Waistband` + `Jorts`/`BeltLatch` (`QS-A` ~0.56 ms, `QS-B` MAC-free Shamir) + `Corduroy`/`Hem` $K$-to-1 WHIR/`[CWYZ26]` (`Habr24Qrom128` & `BciksJohnsonQrom128`) + `qsag-migrate` 438-rep co-ZK + RX 6750 XT Vulkan ($2^{20}$ Poseidon2 Merkle `38.77 ms` / `204.6×` CPU) + 6-kernel Lean replay | **L3–L4** | Persistent GPU VRAM WHIR session (`629779a`) & `AVX-512`/`GFNI`/`SHA-NI`; close `[CWYZ26]` Lemmas 4.5/4.7 (`NonExcludedBound`); regenerate ELF `.text` CT fixtures (`audit_elf_ct.py`); cut Beam mock verify from `75.4 ms` toward `<8 ms` | 2026-11-14 |
| **CA1** | **Adversarial ACL2, SBCL & Clozure CL Prover/Compiler Audit** ([`~/dev/compiler-audit`](file:///Users/ember/dev/compiler-audit)) | 20 audit reports · standalone `repros/` across `darwin-arm64` & `x86-64-linux` | **126 distinct verified bug classes** (**72 soundness/wrong-code**, **2 security/RCE**, **52 crash/divergence**): 27 `:ttag nil` ACL2 `8.7+` Core `NIL` bugs (7 pure-kernel zero-book/stobj), 12 Community Book `NIL` bugs + `SMTLink` Python RCE, 3 SBCL `2.6.10` `(safety 3)` bugs proving `NIL` in pure ACL2, 2 CCL `1.14` `:ttag nil` `NIL` bugs | **L3** | Upstream filing & host TCB mitigations for ACL2/SBCL systems (`fn` host pinned away from affected optimizations) | 2026-11-13 |
| **SP1** | **Multi-PDK SPICE, PCB EM & TCAD Verification** ([`~/dev/spice-smt-bench`](file:///Users/ember/dev/spice-smt-bench)) | Zero-dep Rust (`spice2smt`) · Mathlib-free Lean 4.35 (`0 sorry`, `0 axiom`) | 19 graded decks across 6 PDKs (`asap7`, `gt2n`, `ihp_sg13g2`, `gan_sic`, `gf180mcu`, `sky130`), PCB DFM, & Scharfetter–Gummel TCAD → `smt2-exp`, `dreal-ode`, & 19 Lean `TranscendentalField` specs; `paving_unsat_sound` + **3/19 `Bench_*` proved** in `Targets.lean` | **L2–L3** | Connect Rust JSON paving output to Lean `PavingNode`; replace `f64` intermediate netlist lexer with exact rational lexing; prove remaining 16 `Bench_*` targets | 2026-11-13 |
| **BS1** | **`breadstuffs` Proving Policy, Blocklace Tie-Break & Client Signer** ([`~/dev/breadstuffs`](file:///Users/ember/dev/breadstuffs)) | 100+ Rust crates · `Dregg2` Lean 4 (`10,639` commits on `origin/main`) | Shipped `Turn::is_coordination` → `not_required` proving disposition (`18b3abebf`, closing Directive 23), unified `blocklace` tie-break (`04c093192` `OPEN-CM-XSORT`, `0 sorry`), and warm `dregg-client-sign` Unix-socket daemon + ingress macaroons (`025e9057a`) | **L3** | Land `DREGG_PROVE_WORKERS=0`, single-vote-per-heartbeat quorum batching, and `DREGG_STORE_CACHE_MB` memory bounds | 2026-11-14 |
| **MD1** | **`minidregg` Physical Authority Cells, Simplex Faithfulness & Append Growth** ([`~/dev/minidregg`](file:///Users/ember/dev/minidregg)) | Lean 4 + Rust (`8,728` commits on `origin/main`; `315` `minidregg-lanes/*`) | Physical `.authority` cutover to `CredentialAuthorityLayout` (`ea25a8d9c`, `lake build Minidregg` green), hashed-bits-first private roots (`ec9749280`), `RelativeFaithful` Simplex induction (`538456cbf`), log-format-6 erasable commit floor (`aac9eba60`) | **L3** | `append-growth` (`5e05cf4fc`) single-pass private index evaluation & `grain-runtime` `quiescence preflight` | 2026-11-14 |
| **FN1** | **Promoted `fn` Persistent Event Log & Falsifiable Assurance Pilots** ([`~/dev/fn`](file:///Users/ember/dev/fn)) | 203 ACL2 books (`91.5K` LOC, `3,093` `defthm`s, `95` `:owed` stubs) · 366 Lean 4 files (`431.9K` LOC) | Promoted `fn2` to repo root (`49787612f`); Nov 13 Assurance Audit (`9849fcebe`) documented `:owed` durability/budget/native obligations and executed counterexample (`319620bed`) refuting `durable-turn-inv-p` | **L2** | Execute 6 interface pilots (`P0` semantic `defwitness-owed`, `P1` `reachable-durable-state-p`, `P2` `POST` vertical slice, `P3` budgets, `P4` host refinement, `P5` closure-wide Lean cert) | 2026-11-13 |
| **CV1** | **`cv` (`clustervision`) Unified State Plane & `v0.20` Swarm** ([`~/dev/cv`](file:///Users/ember/dev/cv)) | Rust (`2,830` linear commits, 22 harnesses) | `v0.19.3`+ (`d95e2143`): unified SQLite WAL `~/.clustervision/state.db`, Zstd-Seekable `packs/` + `cv serve --hub`, positional trigram `--exact`, `cv blame`, `cv hook receipt`, `cv lanes --stranded` | **L4** | `v0.20` swarm (`agy_native`, `agy_coverage`, `atomic_index`, `fidelity`) | 2026-11-14 |

### I-B. `obend` + `obebuilder` (`obb v6`/`v7`) Cathedral Register (`StageBInstances.lean` Sealed)

| ID | Organ / Initiative (`obend` + `obb v6`/`v7`) | Tri-Model Squads | Quarried Donors | Wave C1–C3 Ground Truth (`16fed219` / `aab42d2`) | Rung Now | Active Stage-2C / Post-C3 Frontier | Last Report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **M0** | **`obb v6`/`v7` Metaharness, Anti-Tautology Lints & Receipt Broker** (`~/dev/obebuilder`) | Gemini × Codex Astra × Claude Fable | Row 7 (iteration speed), [`~/dev/lean-transport`](file:///Users/ember/dev/lean-transport) (`44fae29`) | `obebuilder` `a672a67` (`obb v6`) / `aab42d2` (`obb v7`, 12 CLI subcommands): `obb harness`, `obb state`, `lean/judge-fragment-restates-check`, `lean/pigeonhole-vacuous-premise`, `cross-lang/domain-tag-drift`, 3-way proof/test/`#tooth` separation (`lean/test-in-library`), HMAC-authenticated SHA-bound `JudgeReceipt`s; `obend/quarry/obend-apex.toml` (238 apex entries) | **L3–L4** | Reconcile `obebuilder/quarry/obend-quarry.toml` status markers (`5/40` marked `uptaken`) with Wave C2/C3 reality; full cone-cached receipt enforcement | 2026-11-14 |
| **O1** | **`Core4`, Equi-Recursive Types, `2L-GOCTT` & `(Co)Algebra` Repair** (`Obend/{Core,Category,Repair,Paco,Slot,Tactic}`) | Claude Fable × Gemini × Codex Astra | Row 5, `lean-transport`, `breadstuffs` `EvidencedFrame` | Wave C1a (`4246ad20`) wired `MachineFast` into `Run.Ticks`, sealed `EquiRecursiveAgreement` (`Obend/Core/Term.lean`), purged barrel fossils; Wave C3 (`16fed219`) hardened `AutoCert` receiver qualification & `WorkbookEngine` redaction | **L3** | Active worktree `swarm-s2-cubical-core-43d56b4d` (`ee922ed0`) & `swarm-s2-live-cli-ac3ec0c7` (`65256788`) | 2026-11-14 |
| **O2** | **Dual-Track Crypto Spine, `SymbolicZk` & Sumcheck Binding** (`Obend/{Crypto,SymbolicZk,Judge}`) | Codex Astra × Claude Fable × Gemini | Rows 2, 6, 15, `dclutch` KKT | Wave C2 sealed `StageBInstances.lean` (`0 *Obligations`); Wave C3 (`7b91227f`..`16fed219`) sealed P0 soundness bugs in `SymbolicZk`, `CompileToPiop` sumcheck binding, and `Transcript` squeeze phase (while standalone PQ custody/WHIR scales in `qsag`) | **L3** | Cross-pollinate `qsag`'s constructive `0 Classical.choice` `[CWYZ26]` / `BciksJohnsonQrom128` profiles | 2026-11-13 |
| **O3** | **ZK-OCap `Polis`, 256-Bucket `WorldTree` Vault & `seL4` Verifier** (`Obend/{Polis,Vault,Ledger}`, `crates/obend-sel4-verifier`) | Claude Fable × Codex Astra × Gemini | Rows 4, 10, `breadstuffs` (`dregg-auth`, `captp`) | 256-bucket COW Verkle `Obend/Vault/WorldTree.lean` + torn-write WAL; `stageB_polis_deos_trace_sealed` proved with `0 *Obligations` (`4d2cc0e0`); legacy `crates/obend-node` & `sandstorm/` retired (`3df8eb96`) in favor of `obend-{ffi,sandbox,gui,crypto-exec,sel4-verifier,pq-mpc}` | **L3** | Live `seL4` Microkit hardware-in-the-loop canopy deployment | 2026-11-13 |
| **O4** | **`SymbolicZkVM`, Ranked Logic `Reasons` & `DatalogCert`** (`Obend/{Leaf,Lower,Reasons,Logic}`, `Hardware/Hvm`) | Gemini × Claude Fable × Codex Astra | Row 1, `breadstuffs` `Dregg2/Datalog` (`64e2caf1b`), `WpGenerator`; **`Oracle7` severed** | `Obend/Logic/{DatalogCert,CircuitDerive}.lean` + unified GL/VGRS `Obend.Reasons` + complete `LawDial` `solveLawWitness`; `obb v5` `lean/judge-fragment-restates-check` enforces non-tautological `Judge.Fragment` across all organs | **L3** | Higher-order sharing & sparse $\mathcal{K}$-semiring scale benchmarks | 2026-11-13 |
| **O5** | **Span-Bound Parsing (`VpaJson`/`PredRE`) & `ZkStripe` Call-Trees** (`CathedralApex.lean`, `StageBInstances.lean`) | Claude Fable × Codex Astra × Gemini | Rows 1, 9 (`tlsn`), 11 ($\omega$), 12 (Det-CBOR `TreeAut`) | `stageB_zkstripe_calltree_sealed` proved in `StageBInstances.lean` (`0 *Obligations`); broken `ByteClassMask` replaced by `VpaJson` escape-aware parsing | **L3** | Corpus-scale streaming `VpaJson` + `SameOpening` benchmarks | 2026-11-13 |
| **O6** | **AI Cluster Governance, `Ozaki` Exact Collectives & `svenvs` Safety Cages** (`Obend/ClusterGov`, `StageBInstances.lean`) | Codex Astra × Gemini × Claude Fable | Rows 3, 4, 8, 13, 16, 19 (`AriadneStep`), `svenvs` (`06f03eb`) | `stageB_clustergov_ozaki_step_sealed` proved (`0 *Obligations`); `SM-PUF` / `FingerprintUnclonable` struck per Nov 12 physical audit; Wave C3 sealed `Epistemic` & `Hybrid` bounds | **L3** | Multi-node `Ozaki` + `AriadneStep` hardware runbook | 2026-11-13 |
| **O7** | **5-Stage `SiliconElabFabric`, RDNA2 Binary Validation, Numerics & Device Physics** (`Obend/{Lower,Hardware,Analysis}`) | Codex Astra × Claude Fable × Gemini | Rows 14, 17–18, `spice-smt-bench` | Consolidated `72 → 9` GPU/Lower/Analysis modules (`39dba74f`); `stageB_lean_fpga_rung2_to_rung5_sealed` proved (`0 *Obligations`) with `FaceIdeal3` (`BitVec 27`, replacing refuted `CofibLUT16`); 29/29 RDNA2 RX 6750 XT dumps certified; Wave C3 sealed `Enclosure`, `SosLyapunov`, `Flowpipe`, `QuantumWalk` | **L3** | Active `Hardware/Device/{DriftDiffusion,Enclosure,Wafer}.lean` edits + `swarm-s2-{hw-silicon,pde-gpu}` worktrees | 2026-11-14 |

### Resolution of Earlier Open Decisions (`2026-11-12` to `2026-11-14`)
- **Multi-pillar topology vs. single-repo freeze:** `obend` (`dev`) is the converged home for the language/vault/silicon/DeOS synthesis (`StageBInstances.lean` sealed), while `qsag`, `compiler-audit`, `spice-smt-bench`, `breadstuffs`, `minidregg`, `fn`, and `cv` advance as focused independent repositories.
- **Row 5 vacuous `ProofProducing` local-reading demos & tautological `Judge` fragments:** Outlawed mechanically by `obebuilder` (`obb v5`/`v6`: `lean/judge-fragment-restates-check`, `lean/pigeonhole-vacuous-premise`, `lean/test-in-library`).
- **Row 10 reconstructed-model `R3` & narrow `<128b` welds:** Reconstructed model-head credit retired; `Obend/Vault/WorldTree.lean` (256-bucket) + `Obend/Polis` enforce full-width digests (`lean/narrow-digest-weld`).
- **Refuted Nov 11 hardware/parsing sketches (`ByteClassMask`, `SM-PUF`, `CofibLUT16`):** Replaced in Wave C2/C3 by `VpaJson`, struck `FingerprintUnclonable`, and `FaceIdeal3` (`BitVec 27`).
- **Legacy `Oracle7` & 73-bit BabyBear floor:** `Oracle7` severed (`9396b68`); new PQ/IOP systems enforce 128-bit QROM floors (`qsag` `Habr24Qrom128` / `BciksJohnsonQrom128` and `obend` `DualPCS`).

---

## II. Preserved Historical Pre-Consolidation Register (`2026-11-06` to `2026-11-07` Baseline)

*Preserved verbatim below as the historical baseline (`51f12a6` / Nov 7) audited in `ASTRA-DIRECTION-REVIEW-2026-11-07.md` prior to the Nov 8–12 `obend` + `obb v2` consolidation (`obb quarry` donor mapping shown in Section I above).*

Rule for every lane (Nov 6–7): **ground first**. Before building, scout what /Users/ember/dev/breadstuffs, minidregg,
zkml-research, degg-research, DreggNet, drorb and the whatember dossiers already have for the problem, write
GROUNDING.md (what exists, what is reused, what is replaced and why), then build on it. Never re-invent what is
there; never keep what is there only because it is there.

| # | Initiative | Owner lane | Repo | Rung (Nov 7) | Bar | Next gate (as of Nov 7) | Last report |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Parser/language excellence (policy language, demos, perf, Lean-first AIR generator, build) | parser deputy gen 2 (Claude) | breadstuffs | L2-L3 | policy language elab+compile proved; two public demos; generator kills hand-written AIR; `make check-fast` < 2 min | demo (a) table now policyc (4b0146d52); union compile 1,515 s -> 28.9 s (7f0c7efae) -> 0.83 s (f45ef0ba5, proved-equal fast paths, bytes identical); `make check-fast` 13.9 s measured (bar met) and pinned equal to the crate table after minimize (db96c58ca); umbrella floor-ratchet green again (86db29a82, DfaRouting repair, no baseline growth); law1 classifier repaired (7b1f3657c). direct-logic front end cut over to the Lean compiler with program_sound/complete and a two-hot refusal control, law1 row 3 -> 0 (520727fb2, 3501b00f9). demo (b) real-session projection removed (939d676cc; synthetic is the demo). counted repeats \w{64} 4.38 s -> 0.62 s (20ab02054, hash-carrying normalizer, proved equal, bytes identical). In flight: in-process dregg-lean-ffi compiler (ember decision), zkOracle chain generator (generator lane declined it; custom-leaf stays with us, next); counted-repeat determinizer (simDecide) next perf target | 2026-11-07 *(quarried → `O4`/`O5`)* |
| 2 | Tower256 certificate leaf prover | Tower256 gen 5 (done) | minidregg main `dcf53d2d1` | L3 | native 9104 kernel byte-identical to Lean on 5 vectors; ContentCert gaps closed (automaton root; nonempty-trace DfaAccepts iff); HonestRun 934 s → 45 s, FinalPolynomialCheck 12.3 GiB → 3.4 GB; umbrella green | next: ContentCert over a served automata AIR leaf; GPU prover via init 17 | 2026-11-06 *(quarried → `O2` UDR)* |
| 3 | Dark learning (MPC custody, HE helpers, collaborative ZK proof, handover) | dark-learning gen 6 (deploy, prep, verifier, train lanes) | zkml-research (native/) | L2 | three custodians on forge/bb2/hbox over pinned TLS with distributed keys; real sealed MASCOT/LowGear tapes made per box; d = 4096 GEN6 step 94 s wired / 791 s via hbox; proof 2^-101/step (F_p^2), 43-47 MB, pipelined; handover rotation + self-handover with erasure all green; release M = 52 fits 12 GB/seat; budget 2000 steps 2^-15; MNIST plaintext 86.6% @2000 | run of record (N = 8, handover after 6, release) scheduled to end ~Nov 10 20:00 UTC; Python replay at d = 4096; 2,000-step run needs a wired third box (ember) | 2026-11-07 *(bounded record kept; superseded → `O2`/`O6` `Tulva`+`Sable`)* |
| 4 | Governance device + attestation (seL4 chokepoint, NVIDIA/Blackwell, Chutes) | governance successor | degg-research, breadstuffs | L3 | IRQ exposure fixed; virtio TX; runtime halt falsifier; Blackwell verified live; narrator gate on | CAKEML-ROUTE.md, Blackwell | 2026-11-06 *(quarried → `O3`/`O6`)* |
| 5 | HOL4-Lean bridge (panSem export, row contracts, install) | bridge follow-on (done) | DreggNet, breadstuffs, degg-research | L3 | 64 contracts; Mac install 60 s; ladder on exported evaluate | ember: ledger policy A/B; vacuous demos | 2026-11-06 *(vacuous wrappers retired; quarried → `O1`)* |
| 6 | Mina/Pickles emitter rescue | rescue lane | breadstuffs | L0 | every module < 4 GB / 60 s or retired with census | census + diagnosis | opened 2026-11-06 *(superseded → `O2` `DualPCS`)* |
| 7 | Iteration speed | iteration lane (today's scope done) | minidregg, breadstuffs, redregg | L2 | 8 modules fixed (ObjectLaw 16.5→2.7 GB, PiDeclarationDeployed 14.6→6.1, RotatedKernel 14.2→3.7, HostTeethProofs 8.3→1.45…); olean snapshots portable across machines/OS; make check-fast/check-full/boxes in both repos; policy + pin rules documented | ember: switch shared .lake/packages; bb2 flock shim; breadstuffs-codex Mathlib 7 GB; next: import Mathlib trimming (31 modules at 6.4 GB floor), TokenCensus, compiled guard exes | 2026-11-06 *(converged → `M0` `obb cone` + `obb broker`)* |
| 8 | Audit theorem over a bit-exact recompute of gpt-oss-20b (FlashProve kept as a comparison point) | init-8 lane | zkml-research, minidregg, breadstuffs | L3 (G1-G5 reached; 2026-11-07) | gptoss-int v0 bit-identical on Mac, x86, T4, TPU v5e (layer 0); 24 layers agree with float64 at 301/302; auditor recomputes fail-closed with compiled-Lean verdicts (9 live receipts); steered transcripts accepted by a logit-tolerance checker and refused by exact recompute, on real weights | 24 layers in JAX on accelerator; a bf16 GPU server as the honest float backend | 2026-11-07 `docs/EXACT-RECOMPUTE.md`; Lean `c9717142f` *(quarried → `O6` `Ozaki`+`Sable`)* |
| 9 | Attested transport + receipts (MPC-TLS call-tree certificates) | lane 9 (done) | breadstuffs | L3 | real tree: glm-5.3-flash → self-signed tool server → example.com, 4 MPC-TLS hops, 3 dataflow edges over authenticated bytes, key hidden; stranger re-verify from fresh GitHub clone ACCEPT in 57 s; 10 tamper classes refused | ember: keep bb2 notary/tool server running; publish call-tree page; independent notary; next: typed edges by call id, freshness challenge, renter-anchored root | 2026-11-06 `99204bcb9` *(quarried → `O5` `ZkStripe`)* |
| 10 | Third-party verification of a real Claude Code session (R0-R3) | NEW | breadstuffs, cv | L2 | a stranger verifies a cv-exported session through R3 with no host trust; microsite | GROUNDING.md | opened 2026-11-06 *(model-head retired; executor-faithful → `M0`/`O3`)* |
| 11 | Streaming certificates (prefix receipts over a live log, Büchi/ω) | streaming lane | breadstuffs | L3 (cross-model audit owed) | ω-automaton with three-valued verdict, window_sound/windows_compose, Büchi visit count (liveness never certified true from a prefix); stream-check follower; live runs to 27,775 lines; a real `git add -A` caught | ember: Codex re-auth; publish so-far page; publish window files | 2026-11-06 `1f2569bd7` *(quarried → `O5`/`O6`)* |
| 12 | Tree automata over JSON/CBOR | tree lane (done) | breadstuffs | L2→L3 local | deterministic CBOR (not JCS: JCS aliases 2^53+1), canon_injective, schema_sound, path/corpus certificates via extracted `tree-check`; over 3,382 real tool calls: 13 mentions of `pkill -f`, 0 at the byte pattern; 18 tampers refused | ember: publish certificates+corpus; push microsite 59a5fdb; salted leaf digests; move onto Tower256 leaf | 2026-11-06 *(quarried → `O5` Det-CBOR `TreeAut`)* |
| 13 | Eval-provenance / model-identity receipt | init-13 lane | zkml-research, dregg-microsites | L3 (strict mode waits on H100 recompute of E3) | receipt over real Llama 4 Maverick: own §11 conversion reproduces FlashProve wsums digest over 232 GB; per-expert cSHAKE roots; Lean identity_sound/hollow_refused; which-model page live | ember: who signs a real eval (H100 recompute of FlashProve dropped by ember) | 2026-11-06 `45f11ea9` *(quarried → `O6` Passport CWT)* |
| 14 | Hardware: tensor-core exactness model (F3) + holography accumulation (F4) | init-14 lane (done to L1) | zkml-research, minidregg lane/mma-exact, degg-research, redregg | L1 | F3 counts model + checked Lean exactness per accumulator + GPU protocol ready; F4 verdict "adapt" (no cheaper hash-based accumulation; keep commitment-free structure accumulation for later) | ember: one hour on a B300/B200 (+H100) | 2026-11-06 `b21d99d6` *(converged → `O2` `PikkuFold` + `O6`/`O7` `Ozaki`/RDNA2)* |
| 15 | ArkLib: Selvage keystone derived from ArkLib's merged state-restoration theorem (finite alphabets); review draft finds no adaptive-adversary test in ArkLib's SR suite | init-15 lane (done) | minidregg lane/arklib-sr-bridge, zkml-research | L1 | bridge green (4,082 jobs, no sorry); coupling lemma proved; two codex checks; retirement list (recommend keep as cross-check) | ember: infinite-alphabet closure; post review; adaptive-test PR to ArkLib; blueprint (c) | 2026-11-06 `f00e39c75` *(quarried → `O2`/`O6` `AuditSampling`)* |
| 16 | Unlearning / forgetting certificates (C18-C20) | init-16 lane | zkml-research, minidregg lane/unlearning-certs | L2 | exact deletion for C18/C19 on UCI optdigits, 22/22 attacks refused, SGD as a bound, custody on Pedersen commitments, PQ commitment | umbrella + merge; ember: transcript leak, custody release, PQ commitment | 2026-11-06 `2c7013d5` *(quarried → `O6` `ClusterGov`)* |
| 17 | Accelerator readiness: dark-learning BFV kernels, Tower256 GPU prover, tensor-core probe; emulate locally, tune on Kaggle T4/TPU, one-hour runbooks for paid boxes | accel-readiness lane | zkml-research, degg-research | L0 | each workload passes a Kaggle dry run; RUNBOOK with box spec and cost; no paid hardware until ready | GROUNDING.md | opened 2026-11-06 *(converged → `O2`/`O7` `hbox` RX 6750 XT `BOLT-FHE`/RDNA2)* |
| 18 | TPU first-principles performance: bound per kernel, static HLO/Pallas checks on the Mac, Kaggle profiles as %-of-bound; MXFP4 recompute, BFV NTT, sumcheck-as-matmul at ≥95% | tpu-perf lane | zkml-research | L0→L1 (deviceless TPU compile works on hbox: real libtpu compiler, v5e/v6e/v5p/v4) | rerunnable bound + static check + measured %-of-bound per kernel; ≥95% or named gap; project TPU style guide | bound calculator + HLO inspector on hbox; explain int8 dot copy fusions | 2026-11-06 `b14717f6` *(preserved as count-model note per Astra §4)* |
| 19 | Veil 2.0 vs our temporal/program logics; Ariadne state continuity for the chokepoint device | veil lane | zkml-research notes/veil, veil-pilot, degg-research chokepoint-step | L2 | census; Veil read; two-protocol pilot; Ariadne modelled, model-checked, kernel-proved, refinement into the Veil model, BLAKE3 byte export | done: device kernel-proved (`248f1cf`); Veil model `1f83fe8`; refinement `refines` (device step is a forward simulation of the Veil model, one-increment control does not simulate) veil-pilot `10fb360` (local); byte step with BLAKE3, `stepBytes_complete`/`stepBytes_sound`, `@[export dregg_chokepoint_ariadne_step]` `ed3ee50` (green on 4.33.1 and 4.35.0). Next: HOL4 bridge consumes the export; hex layer still tested, not proved | 2026-11-06 *(quarried → `O1` `Loom` + `O6` `AriadneStep`)* |

Historical Nov 7 decisions footer (preserved from `51f12a6`; see Section I above for Nov 12 resolutions):
(initiative 1 transcript.json: decided 2026-11-07, removed in 939d676cc); ledger policy A/B and the three vacuous
ProofProducing demos (5); 3 vs 5 custodians (3); chokepoint home in minidregg (4); keep/move/delete the Mac shared
mathlib cache (7); whether to apply for an H100 on the VCF cluster (8); whether a GPU may be used for 14 (vast is not
ours to use without ember's word); whether we contribute the Merkle-adapter/BCS blueprint upstream (15c).
